Tokyo needs to get over the G8

In the wake of a 2010 flare-up over the Senkaku (Diaoyu) Islands – when a Chinese trawler collided with Japanese Coast Guard vessels – Robert Dujarric outlines a strategy for Tokyo to emerge diplomatically stronger. He notes that although Japan released the Chinese captain (under pressure) and was seen as having “caved,” China’s aggressive reaction actually hurt Beijing’s image regionally. To capitalize on this, Dujarric suggests Japan take a measured, statesmanlike approach. One bold recommendation is for Japan to formally drop its claim to Dokdo/Takeshima, islands controlled by South Korea. By doing so, Tokyo would remove a historical thorn with Seoul and present itself as magnanimous, thereby tightening cooperation with Korea against any Chinese coercion.

Additionally, Dujarric advises Japan to keep emphasizing the contrast in behavior: Japan should respond calmly and lawfully to incidents, underscoring its commitment to a rules-based order versus China’s intimidation. Internationally, Tokyo ought to clearly articulate its legal claims and commitment to dialogue to win support. These steps, he argues, would strengthen Japan’s overall standing in Asia and rally others behind it, indirectly shoring up its position on the Senkakus without resorting to force. Ultimately, the Pacific Forum brief paints a picture of strategic restraint and alliance-building as Japan’s best tools to handle the Senkaku dispute amid China’s rise.